Does Planet Earth Have a Thoughts of Its Personal?


This picture of Earth was compiled utilizing tens of hundreds of pictures from the Copernicus Sentinel-2 mission. Because of the satellite tv for pc period, we’re higher positioned to know the complexities of our planet, notably with respect to world change. At the moment’s satellites are used to reply essential to know how Earth works as a system and the way pure processes are altering underneath the stress of human exercise. Satellites additionally present important data for on a regular basis functions corresponding to to enhance agricultural practices, for maritime security and to assist when pure disasters strike. Credit score: Accommodates modified Copernicus Sentinel knowledge (2019–20), processed by ESA and cloud layer from NASA

What’s humanity? Do our minds set us aside from the remainder of nature and from the remainder of Earth? Or does Earth have a collective thoughts of its personal, and we’re merely a part of that thoughts? On the literal face of it, that final query may sound ridiculous.

However a brand new thought experiment explores it extra deeply, and whereas there’s no agency conclusion about humanity and a planetary thoughts, simply eager about it invitations minds to rethink their relationship with nature.

Overcoming our challenges requires a greater understanding of ourselves and nature, and the identical is true for some other civilizations that make it previous the Nice Filter.

Four Stages of Planets

In a self-described “thought experiment,” College of Rochester astrophysicist Adam Frank and colleagues David Grinspoon on the Planetary Science Institute and Sara Walker at Arizona State College use scientific idea and broader questions on how life alters a planet, to posit 4 phases to explain Earth’s previous and potential future. Credit score: College of Rochester illustration / Michael Osadciw

Humanity is fairly pleased with itself typically. We’ve constructed a more-or-less world civilization, we’ve worn out lethal ailments, and we’ve traveled to the Moon. We’re so good we’re taking steps to guard Earth from the kind of calamitous affect that worn out Earth’s earlier tenants, the dinosaurs. However that’s only one perspective.

One other perspective says that we’re nonetheless primitive. That billions of us are within the grip of historical superstitions. That nuclear warfare haunts us like a specter. That tribalism nonetheless drives us to do horrible animalistic issues to at least one one other. That we’re not smart sufficient to handle our personal technological development.

Each views are equally legitimate. All that may actually be stated is that we’re not as primitive as we was once, however we’re nowhere close to as mature as we have to be if we hope to persist past the Nice Filter.

Earth Juno Flyby 2013

The Juno spacecraft took this picture of Earth throughout a gravity help flyby of our planet in 2013. The truth that we are able to make a spacecraft take an image of our house planet is an indication of intelligence. However how clever are we actually? Credit score: NASA/JPL-Caltech/SwRI/MSSS/Kevin M. Gill

Can we give you a strategy to clarify what stage we’re at in our growth? The authors of a brand new article suppose they will. They usually suppose we are able to solely try this if we bear in mind Earth’s planetary historical past, the collective thoughts, and the state of our know-how.

This trio of scientists wrote the brand new article within the Worldwide Journal of Astrobiology. It’s titled “Intelligence as a planetary scale course of.” The authors are Adam Frank from the College of Rochester, David Grinspoon from the Planetary Science Institute, and Sara Walker from Arizona State College. The article is a thought experiment based mostly on our scientific understanding of Earth alongside questions on how life has altered and continues to change the planet.

People have a tendency to think about intelligence as a property belonging to people. Nevertheless it’s additionally a property belonging to collectives. Social bugs use their collective intelligence to make choices. The authors take the concept of intelligence even additional: from particular person intelligence to collective intelligence, to planetary intelligence. “Right here, we broaden the concept of intelligence as a collective property and lengthen it to the planetary scale,” the authors write. “We take into account the methods by which the looks of technological intelligence might characterize a form of planetary-scale transition, and thus may be seen not as one thing which occurs on a planet however to a planet, a lot as some fashions suggest the origin of life itself was a planetary phenomenon.”

We’ve divided Earth’s life varieties into species. We acknowledge that evolution drove the event of all these species. However are we lacking one thing in our urge to categorise? Is it extra right to view life as planetary quite than as particular person species? In spite of everything, species didn’t all of the sudden seem; every one appeared in an ongoing chain of evolution. (Aside from the unique species, whose origins stay clouded in thriller.) And all species are linked collectively within the biosphere. It’s usually identified that Earth is a bacterial world and the remainder of us are solely right here due to micro organism.

It’s worthwhile to recall the work of Vladimir Vernadsky. Vernadsky was an essential founding father of biogeochemistry. Wikipedia defines biogeochemistry as “… the scientific self-discipline that includes the examine of the chemical, bodily, geological, and organic processes and reactions that govern the composition of the pure surroundings (together with the biosphere, the cryosphere, the hydrosphere, the pedosphere, the ambiance, and the lithosphere).

Vernadsky noticed that the biosphere system is strongly linked to the Earth’s non-living methods. It’s obscure the biosphere with out taking a look at the way it’s linked with different methods just like the ambiance. The linkage permits the biosphere to form Earth’s different “spheres.”

Vernadsky wrote: “Activated by radiation, the matter of the biosphere collects and redistributes photo voltaic vitality and converts it finally into free vitality able to doing work on Earth. A brand new character is imparted to the planet by this highly effective cosmic pressure. The radiations that pour upon the Earth trigger the biosphere to tackle properties unknown to lifeless planetary surfaces, and thus rework the face of the Earth.”

Of their article, the authors level out how organisms modified Earth’s biosphere. When the flexibility to photosynthesize appeared in lifeforms, particular person lifeforms used it to nice profit. However collectively, they oxygenated Earth’s ambiance within the Nice Oxygenation Occasion (GOE.) The photosynthesizers opened a pathway for their very own continuation and for extra complicated life to develop. It not solely modified the course of evolution, however it additionally modified the very geology and geochemistry of the planet. The authors liken the collective exercise of photosynthetic organisms to collective intelligence.

Geosphere Biosphere Technosphere

This determine from the article illustrates multi-level networks as a property of planetary-scale operation of intelligence. Every layer of the coupled planetary methods constitutes its personal community of chemical and bodily interactions. Particular nodes in every layer characterize hyperlinks connecting the layers. Thus, the geosphere incorporates chemical/bodily networks related to processes corresponding to atmospheric circulation, evaporation, condensation, and weathering. These are modified by the biosphere through extra networks of processes corresponding to microbial chemical processing and leaf transpiration. The technosphere provides an extra layer of networked processes corresponding to industrial-scale agriculture, manufacturing byproducts and vitality technology. Credit score: Frank et al. 2022

“Making sense of how a planet’s intelligence may be outlined and understood helps shine a little bit mild on humanity’s future on this planet—or lack thereof,” they write. “If we ever hope to outlive as a species, we should use our intelligence for the larger good of the planet,” stated Adam Frank.

That gained’t come as a shock to Universe At the moment readers.

The authors level out how collective exercise adjustments the planet. They base their experiment partly on the Gaia speculation, which says that the Earth’s non-biological methods—geochemistry, plate tectonics, the ambiance, the oceans—work together with residing methods to keep up your entire planet in a liveable state. With out the “collective intelligence” of the organic world, the Earth wouldn’t be liveable.

The authors use an instance from forests as an instance the purpose.

Earth’s nice forests couldn’t exist with out the community of mycorrhizal fungi that reside under floor. Tree roots work together with the community and the community strikes vitamins round within the forest. The fungi get carbon in return. With out this community, the timber couldn’t survive, and no nice forests would emerge.

Mycorrhizal Network

Mycorrhizal fungi are in a symbiotic relationship with crops. The connection is normally mutualistic, the fungus offering the plant with water and minerals from the soil and the crops offering the fungus with photosynthesis merchandise. Parasitic organisms are additionally a part of the community. Picture Credit score: By Charlotte Roy, Salsero35, Nefronus – CC BY-SA 4.0

As schoolchildren, we study that crops produce the oxygen we have to breathe. With out photosynthetic organisms, we couldn’t survive. So the collective exercise of the plant world (and algae, and so forth.) adjustments the planet to a spot hospitable for humanity and different complicated life. However now in our brief time on Earth, we’ve developed know-how, which is probably the most highly effective expression of our collective planetary intelligence. What does that imply for Earth?

The authors discuss 4 phases of Earth’s growth and the way we are able to perceive the concept of collective planetary intelligence as these phases evolve.

“Planets evolve by means of immature and mature phases, and planetary intelligence is indicative of whenever you get to a mature planet.”
Adam Frank, co-author, “Intelligence as a planetary scale course of.”

The primary stage is an immature biosphere. Billions of years in the past the Earth was an immature biosphere. The one lifeform was micro organism, which couldn’t exert a lot pressure on Earth’s planetary methods. Due to this, there was no essential world suggestions between life and the planet. There was no collective intelligence.

The second stage was a mature biosphere. This was about 2.5 billion to 540 million years in the past. Photosynthesis appeared after which crops. Photosynthesis oxygenated Earth’s ambiance and an ozone layer developed. Life was making the Earth extra steady and hospitable for itself. That is the collective planetary intelligence the authors are speaking about.

Immature Mature Biosphere

Earth’s immature biosphere and mature biosphere phases. The mature biosphere stage was solely potential as soon as photosynthetic organisms created suggestions with Earth’s non-biological processes, oxygenating the ambiance and creating an ozone layer. Credit score: College of Rochester illustration / Michael Osadciw

The third stage is the place we’re at now, in line with the authors. We reside in an immature technosphere of our personal creation. Our communication, transportation, electrical, and governmental networks are more and more linked right into a technosphere. A fast scan of headlines in client tech media exhibits how we are able to get a little bit enthusiastic about what we’ve created as a species (Meta, anybody?) Nevertheless it’s smart to not get too excited. Why?

As a result of our technosphere just isn’t linked with pure methods. Our immature technosphere largely ignores its affect on the Earth’s ambiance, oceans, and the biosphere basically. We extract fossil fuels and push carbon into the ambiance in an unregulated method. The hazard is that this technological immaturity will pressure the Earth’s methods right into a state that imperils the technosphere itself. The immature technosphere is working towards itself and the biosphere that helps it.

The fourth stage represents a workable future. It’s the mature technosphere, and in a mature technosphere, our technological intelligence advantages the Earth. For instance, renewable vitality sources like photo voltaic vitality will displace fossil fuels and assist the local weather regulate itself and keep its habitability. Technological agriculture will strengthen the Earth’s soil methods quite than degrade them. We’ll use our know-how to construct cities that co-exist with pure methods quite than dominating them. However there are numerous unknowns.

Immature Mature Technosphere

Earth’s immature technosphere and mature technosphere phases. The mature technosphere stage shall be potential after we use our know-how to keep up Earth’s life-supporting methods quite than to degrade them. Credit score: College of Rochester illustration / Michael Osadciw

“Planets evolve by means of immature and mature phases, and planetary intelligence is indicative of whenever you get to a mature planet,” Frank says in a press launch. “The million-dollar query is determining what planetary intelligence seems to be like and means for us in follow as a result of we don’t know the right way to transfer to a mature technosphere but.”

In a mature technosphere, methods would work together in mutually helpful methods, just like the timber and the mycorrhizal community in forests. A community of suggestions loops each technological and pure would work intelligently to keep up habitability. This could be a wholly new association, and the complexity would permit new capabilities to emerge. The rising capabilities are one hallmark of a mature technosphere. One other is self-maintenance.

Evolution of Coupled Planetary Systems

This determine from the article is a schematic illustration of the evolution of coupled planetary methods by way of levels of planetary intelligence. The authors suggest 5 potential properties required for a world to indicate cognitive exercise working throughout planetary scales (i.e. planetary intelligence). These are: (1) emergence, (2) dynamics of networks, (3) networks of semantic data, (4) look of complicated adaptive methods, (5) autopoiesis. Totally different levels of those properties seem as a world evolves from abiotic (geosphere) to biotic (biosphere) to technologic (technosphere). Credit score: Frank et al. 2022.

“The biosphere discovered the right way to host life by itself billions of years in the past by creating methods for shifting round nitrogen and transporting carbon,” Frank says. “Now we now have to determine the right way to have the identical form of self-maintaining traits with the technosphere.”

There are some indicators that we’re groping in the direction of a mature technosphere, however they’re principally crisis-driven. In 1987, we banned the ozone-harming class of chemical compounds referred to as chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) after scientists discovered a gap within the ozone layer. Acid rain is brought on by sulfur dioxide and nitrogen dioxide and we’ve developed worldwide agreements to restrict them after scientists discovered that acid rain damages soil, trees, fish, and other aquatic animals. DDT was used to kill pests and malarial mosquitoes but many countries banned their use when scientists found that it persisted in the environment and led to population declines in birds of prey, among other biosphere-harming effects.

Planetary Intelligence Interventions

This figure from the article shows timescales for interventions at different proposed levels of planetary intelligence. For so-called ‘mature biospheres’, feedbacks or interventions occur across a range of timescales from decades (DMS ((dimethyl sulphide) ocean temperature regulation) to millions of years for CH4 climate regulation. For ‘immature technospheres’ where the feedbacks or interventions are inadvertent, timescales occur on decades to century timescales. For ‘mature technospheres’ interventions are intentional and designed to maintain the sustainability of both the biosphere and the technosphere as a coupled system. Ozone replenishment and climate mitigation would occur on decades to century timescales while intentional changes in stellar evolution (if possible) would define the longest timescales at tens to hundreds of millions of years. Credit: Frank et al. 2022.

So there’s been some progress towards planetary intelligence. But those successes are mostly corrections to previous bad behavior. Can we be more proactive?

We might be starting to. We’re developing systems to detect, catalog, and deflect dangerous asteroids that pose a collision hazard with Earth. If we can do that, we can protect the entire biosphere from calamity, along with our own civilization. NASA and the ESA are working on planetary defense, and NASA launched a technology demonstration mission in 2021. If we can use technology to protect the entire planet, that must constitute a step toward a mature technosphere.

Some of these efforts are heartening, but we have a long ways to go, and this thought experiment can help us think more clearly about it. “We don’t have planetary intelligence or a mature technosphere yet,” Frank said. “But the whole purpose of this research is to point out where we should be headed.”

Are the development of planetary intelligence and a mature technosphere hallmarks of civilizations that make it past a “Great Filter?” Maybe. That idea dovetails with Frank’s other work in the search for alien technosignatures on distant exoplanets.

“We’re saying the only technological civilizations we may ever see—the ones we should expect to see—are the ones that didn’t kill themselves, meaning they must have reached the stage of a true planetary intelligence,” he says. “That’s the power of this line of inquiry: it unites what we need to know to survive the climate crisis with what might happen on any planet where life and intelligence evolve.”

For we lifeforms on Earth at this time, Anthropogenic Global Warming is the biggest threat to a sustainable biosphere. While we can debate what it is about our species that drives us to want more stuff, consume more stuff and create more pollution, the debate about AGW itself is over. It’s happening and we’re causing it.

There are some glimmers of planetary intelligence flickering on the horizon. But we’ve got a long way to go yet. Will we become intelligent enough to make it past the climatic Great Filter?

Originally published on Universe Today.

For more on this topic, read Planetary Intelligence: Can a Planet Have a Mind of Its Own?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:



More like this

Translate »